Engagement Rings Vs. Promise Rings: The Ultimate Comparison (2024)

We all must have experienced being young and in love at some point. Realizing this, you want to spread the fantastic news about your significant other to everyone, don't you? What would you do? Buy them flowers, maybe sing ‘Say You Won’t Let Go’ by Sam Smith, or even better, buy them a ring!

A ring is looked at as a special and preciouspiece of jewelry when gifted to a loved one. It does a commendable job of telling your love story. There are mainly two types of rings that couples gift each other. So, if you have planned on buying a stunning ring for your darling, a question must have popped up in your head: “What kind of ring should I gift my partner?” A promise ring or an engagement ring!

Table Of Content
  • Engagement Ring vs. Promise Ring: What is a Promise Ring?
  • Engagement Ring vs. Promise Ring: History of Promise Ring
  • Engagement Ring vs. Promise Ring: What is an Engagement Ring?
  • Engagement Ring vs. Promise Ring: History of an Engagement Ring

A commitment is a meaningful and intimate pledge between two people in a relationship. There is always a way to declare your love for each other and one such way can be by choosing a promise ring for them if you need extra time to say hello to your forever.

With time, you’ll surely want to propose to your partner and also want to introduce them as your fiancé and not your girlfriend/boyfriend. But what remains important here is that you want your commitment to be cherished. So, let’s understand the difference between an engagement ring vs. a promise ring. This will help you make a resounding decision!

Engagement Ring vs. Promise Ring: What is a Promise Ring?

Promise rings convey a deeper devotion to your lover than casual dating. Exchanging promise rings with your partner signifies your love, fidelity, and moral rectitude. These rings are a genuine way to show the person that you care about them in a relationship.Engagement Rings Vs. Promise Rings: The Ultimate Comparison (1)

SHOP Couple Rings

Friendly Diamonds offers a range of couple rings you may pick from to make your promise ring a showpiece. Like engagement rings, which provide an endless array of customization options, these rings are available in various styles and designs.

Endless Love Couple Ringsare a pair of 14kt white gold bands with a contemporary concave hammered texture that combine to create a unique and elegant design.

Everlasting Love Couple Rings, another such beauty, are adorned with a smooth, rounded bow-like pattern and set in 14kt white gold to symbolize eternal love. Generally, when it comes to promise rings, women's bands are more feminine and thinner than men's, which are thicker and matte. Diamonds set in pavé offer a stunning touch and also sparkle as brightly as your love.

Engagement Ring vs. Promise Ring: The History of Promise Rings

Have you ever wondered about the origins and creation of these rings? You have probably figured out what these rings symbolize by now, so, why not now look at their history?

The tradition of promise rings dates back several hundred years, with bishops wearing them as a symbol of spiritual union with the church. Roman brides wore these rings in the 2nd century BC to symbolize permanence and strength. These rings came into fashion as posy rings in England in the 16th century, and were engraved with romantic poems or short messages.

Engagement Rings Vs. Promise Rings: The Ultimate Comparison (2)

SHOP diamond Ring

In the Victorian or Georgian eras, promise rings were introduced as aristocratic rings with gemstones arranged to spell words like regard or love. Today, both men and women can gift and wear promise rings to each other to show their love for each other. Couples mostly wear promise rings on their ring finger, which is the third finger of their left hand.

Engagement Ring vs. Promise Ring: What is an Engagement Ring?

Engagement rings represent the love between two individuals and their eventual marriage proposal. It has been a tradition for years that one partner, with the hopes of getting married, presents the engagement ring to another.

While the recipient of the proposal is traditionally the one to wear the provided engagement ring, many couples today choose to wear engagement bands until they are married and simply place the wedding band stacked below or on top of their engagement ring.

Engagement Rings Vs. Promise Rings: The Ultimate Comparison (3)

SHOP Imperiella Engagement Ring

Check out our stunning engagement rings from Friendly Diamonds before proposing. If you desire to tie the knot, you can present them with an engagement ring.

Imperiella Halo Celtic Knot Diamond Ring features a dazzling gemstone, halo setting, diamond chain link pattern, and intricate tangle knot filigree in its centerpiece and shank.

The central diamond of the Tiara Three Stone Diamond Ring is surrounded by two side stones that look like a crown when seen from the side. The cathedral shank includes pavé set diamonds that reach halfway down each side, oozing modern elegance.

Engagement Ring vs. Promise Ring: History of Engagement Rings

Engagement rings have a long history that spans thousands of years and have evolved through numerous cultures and traditions. Ancient Egypt used weaved reeds or hemp bands to represent love and eternity. Iron rings were provided as a marriage promise in ancient Rome. With jewels and sophisticated patterns, engagement rings became more extravagant in medieval Europe.

They were primarily awarded by royalty and the rich during the Renaissance and Georgian eras. Then the Victorian era saw a boom in engagement rings, specifically diamond ones. As the 20th century progressed, diamond engagement rings were potent symbols of love and fidelity. These rings now represent love, dedication, and the promise of a future together.

Engagement Rings Vs. Promise Rings: The Ultimate Comparison (4)

SHOP Engagement Rings

Hence, whichever ring you choose, whatever it may be, a promise ring or an engagement ring, it means one thing: an undying commitment between two people.

Choosing the right ring completely depends on you and the ring you want. Before buying the ring, check out the wide range available at Friendly Diamonds. Consider a promise ring if the two of you still have miles to go in your relationship.

No matter where you are in your relationship, there is a ring that can symbolize your level of commitment to each other.

Engagement Rings Vs. Promise Rings: The Ultimate Comparison (2024)

FAQs

Is there a difference between engagement rings and promise rings? ›

While engagement rings always represent a couple's commitment to marriage, promise rings can represent a variety of things. Whether it means you're committed to getting engaged down the road or that you're waiting for a special moment, each set of promise rings will contain a unique meaning to the wearers.

Are promise rings worth it? ›

Promise rings can symbolize your faith and commitment with your partner who is not financially able to have a wedding or are not ready for marriage just yet. Although you may not be ready for a marriage, a promise ring represents your commitment to your partner and it is a symbol of your future together.

Does a promise ring go on the same finger as an engagement ring? ›

The most common placement is on the left-hand ring finger(the fourth finger). Then, once an engagement ring is given, the wearer swaps the promise ring to another finger. Another popular choice is to wear your promise ring on the right hand, leaving your wedding ring finger open for a diamond engagement ring.

How much is too much for a promise ring? ›

How Much Should a Promise Ring Cost? There are no rules or guidelines around how much to spend on promise rings, but it's usually less than an engagement ring. At Stambaugh Jewelers, promise rings can be whatever you style fits your desire, and typically range in price from $199 to $2,000.

Is it OK to propose with a promise ring? ›

Since both rings symbolize love, unity, and eternal commitment, you can use a promise ring as an engagement ring if it's the right choice for you and your partner. There's no set rule to being engaged aside from a ring, so the final decision is in your hands.

How much should an engagement ring cost? ›

While engagement rings are a pricy investment, the usual cost tends to be below $10,000, with a national average of $6,000, according to The Knot's 2022 Jewelry and Engagement Study.

Do you get down on one knee for a promise ring? ›

You don't have to drop the knee when presenting a promise ring, as it's not quite as significant as an engagement. Getting down on one knee might also be confusing for your partner if they take it as a marriage proposal. However, that doesn't mean you can't make it special.

Which finger do you wear a purity ring on? ›

Purity Ring Etiquette

They're worn by both young men and women. Usually the ring is worn on the left hand ring finger to serve as an abstinence reminder. If he or she gets married, the wedding ring typically replaces the purity ring. But you can also wear the ring on the right hand or on another finger.

Does a promise ring mean you're engaged? ›

It shows the world that your heart belongs to another and that you're devoted to protecting and nurturing that relationship. These days, a promise ring is most commonly given as a precursor to an engagement—though it can be gifted as just a symbol of love.

Is 25 too old for a promise ring? ›

Is there an age limit for promise rings? We go by the 'never too late' rule. So, we don't believe there's an age limit for a promise ring. That being said, it's always wise to discuss what a promise ring will mean for you and your partner before buying the ring.

Is a promise ring cheesy? ›

However, having researched this topic in a lot of depth over the last few weeks, I think it's time we discard this somewhat cheesy and juvenile idea of the promise ring as it's both outdated and historically incorrect.

What to say when giving a promise ring to a girl? ›

Here are some ideas on what you can say:

I only want to be with you. I love you and want to be with you now and always. Please accept this ring as a promise of my commitment to you. You mean the world to me, and I want to give you this ring as my promise to marry you in the future.

Can a normal ring be a promise ring? ›

It can have a simple solitaire style, featuring one key diamond, or have that perfect pavé sparkle. The physical promise ring can be any ring you want, as long as it is special to you and your partner, then it is perfect!

How to tell if a ring is an engagement ring? ›

Engagement rings are typically made of metal and have a diamond on top. They may have other diamonds or gemstones as well, but the diamond on top is often the highlight of the ring.

How long after a promise ring do you get an engagement ring? ›

There is no set time frame for how long you should wait after receiving a promise ring before getting engaged. It is entirely up to the couple to decide when they are ready to take the next step in their relationship. Some couples may wait a few months, while others may wait a few years.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Carlyn Walter

Last Updated:

Views: 5810

Rating: 5 / 5 (50 voted)

Reviews: 89% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Carlyn Walter

Birthday: 1996-01-03

Address: Suite 452 40815 Denyse Extensions, Sengermouth, OR 42374

Phone: +8501809515404

Job: Manufacturing Technician

Hobby: Table tennis, Archery, Vacation, Metal detecting, Yo-yoing, Crocheting, Creative writing

Introduction: My name is Carlyn Walter, I am a lively, glamorous, healthy, clean, powerful, calm, combative person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.